Securities and Commodities Traders
Buy and sell securities and commodities to transfer debt, capital, or risk. Establish and negotiate unit prices and terms of sale.
AI Impact Summary
Securities and Commodities Traders faces moderate AI displacement risk with a score of 37/100. This occupation has higher AI displacement risk than 71% of all analyzed occupations. Of 22 analyzed tasks, 6 are highly automatable, particularly routine cognitive tasks. Strong protective factors — including social intelligence, creativity, or regulatory barriers — significantly reduce effective risk.
Skill Impact Analysis
AI-Vulnerable Skills (6)
High reliance on Reading Comprehension is a risk area. Consider developing complementary AI-resistant skills to maintain value.
High reliance on Mathematics is a risk area. Consider developing complementary AI-resistant skills to maintain value.
High reliance on Mathematics is a risk area. Consider developing complementary AI-resistant skills to maintain value.
High reliance on Information Ordering is a risk area. Consider developing complementary AI-resistant skills to maintain value.
Programming is AI-vulnerable but has moderate importance in this role. AI tools may handle this; focus on higher-value skills.
Memorization is AI-vulnerable but has moderate importance in this role. AI tools may handle this; focus on higher-value skills.
AI-Resistant Skills (11)
Adaptability/Flexibility is AI-resistant — strengthening this skill provides durable career protection.
Negotiation is AI-resistant — strengthening this skill provides durable career protection.
Social Perceptiveness is AI-resistant — strengthening this skill provides durable career protection.
Persuasion is AI-resistant — strengthening this skill provides durable career protection.
Complex Problem Solving is AI-resistant — strengthening this skill provides durable career protection.
Service Orientation is AI-resistant — strengthening this skill provides durable career protection.
Leadership is AI-resistant — strengthening this skill provides durable career protection.
Coordination is AI-resistant — strengthening this skill provides durable career protection.
AI-Augmented Skills (7)
Recommended Courses
Courses matched to Securities and Commodities Traders skill gaps, ranked by relevance to your displacement risk profile.
Get personalized recommendations. Answer a few questions about your experience and skills to get course suggestions tailored specifically to you.
Upskill to Reduce Risk
Courses addressing your most AI-vulnerable skills
Machine Learning Specialization
by Stanford / DeepLearning.AI
Estimated Impact
AI-Augmentation Tools
Learn to work alongside AI and boost your productivity
Google UX Design Professional Certificate
by Google
Estimated Impact
Strengthen Your Edge
Double down on skills AI can't replicate
Negotiation, Mediation, and Conflict Resolution
by ESSEC Business School
Estimated Impact
We may earn a commission when you enroll through our links, at no extra cost to you. This helps fund the Takeover Tracker.
Risk reduction and salary impact are estimates based on skill gap analysis, course relevance, and labor market data. Actual results vary by individual circumstance.
Education & Training
Percentage of workers at each education and training level
Education Level
Prior Experience Needed
Work experience required to enter this job
Training Provided After Hiring
How long it typically takes to learn on the job
How AI Impacts Each Task
22 tasks analyzed
Make bids or offers to buy or sell securities.
Monitor markets or positions.
Agree on buying or selling prices at optimal levels for clients.
Buy or sell stocks, bonds, commodity futures, foreign currencies, or other securities on behalf of investment dealers.
Report all positions or trading results.
Review securities transactions to ensure conformance to regulations.
Identify opportunities or develop channels for purchase or sale of securities or commodities.
Supervise support staff and ensure proper execution of contracts.
Devise trading, option, or hedge strategies.
Track and analyze factors that affect price movement, such as trade policies, weather conditions, political developments, or supply and demand changes.
Inform other traders, managers, or customers of market conditions, including volume, price, competition, or dynamics.
Receive sales order tickets and inspect forms to determine accuracy of information.
Develop or maintain supplier or customer relationships.
Analyze target companies or investment opportunities to inform investment decisions.
Prepare financial reports, such as reviews of portfolio positions.
Process paperwork for special orders, including margin or option purchases.
Reconcile account-related statements, such as quarterly or annual statements or confirmations.
Report deficiencies in account payments, securities deliveries, or documentation requirements to avoid rule violations.
Write or sign sales order confirmation forms to record or approve security transactions.
Identify or pursue investment strategies related to the green economy, including green hedge funds, renewable energy markets, or clean technology investment opportunities.
Make transportation arrangements for sold or purchased commodities.
Buy, sell, or trade carbon emissions permits.
| Task | AI Capability | Risk | Time % | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Make bids or offers to buy or sell securities. | 62.25Observed | 51.9% | 9% | |
| Monitor markets or positions. | 50.4Observed | 47.2% | 14% | |
| Agree on buying or selling prices at optimal levels for clients. | 30Estimated | 27.0% | 6% | |
| Buy or sell stocks, bonds, commodity futures, foreign currencies, or other securities on behalf of investment dealers. | 64.75Observed | 52.9% | 8% | |
| Report all positions or trading results. | 42.77Observed | 66.3% | 4% | |
| Review securities transactions to ensure conformance to regulations. | 41.67Observed | 65.9% | 4% | |
| Identify opportunities or develop channels for purchase or sale of securities or commodities. | 48.68Observed | 46.5% | 5% | |
| Supervise support staff and ensure proper execution of contracts. | 20Estimated | 23.0% | 3% | |
| Devise trading, option, or hedge strategies. | 55.62Observed | 49.3% | 6% | |
| Track and analyze factors that affect price movement, such as trade policies, weather conditions, political developments, or supply and demand changes. | 52.85Observed | 48.1% | 8% | |
| Inform other traders, managers, or customers of market conditions, including volume, price, competition, or dynamics. | 43.97Observed | 32.6% | 5% | |
| Receive sales order tickets and inspect forms to determine accuracy of information. | 92Estimated | 86.0% | 3% | |
| Develop or maintain supplier or customer relationships. | 15Estimated | 21.0% | 4% | |
| Analyze target companies or investment opportunities to inform investment decisions. | 49.68Observed | 46.9% | 4% | |
| Prepare financial reports, such as reviews of portfolio positions. | 45.83Observed | 67.5% | 3% | |
| Process paperwork for special orders, including margin or option purchases. | 90Estimated | 85.2% | 2% | |
| Reconcile account-related statements, such as quarterly or annual statements or confirmations. | 52.12Observed | 70.1% | 2% | |
| Report deficiencies in account payments, securities deliveries, or documentation requirements to avoid rule violations. | 87Estimated | 84.0% | 2% | |
| Write or sign sales order confirmation forms to record or approve security transactions. | 95Estimated | 87.2% | 2% | |
| Identify or pursue investment strategies related to the green economy, including green hedge funds, renewable energy markets, or clean technology investment opportunities. | 60Estimated | 51.0% | 2% | |
| Make transportation arrangements for sold or purchased commodities. | 87Estimated | 84.0% | 2% | |
| Buy, sell, or trade carbon emissions permits. | 65Estimated | 53.0% | 2% |
Protective Factors
Total protective discount: 27.8%
Essential Soft Skills
Traits that are hard for AI to replicate
Wage & Employment (2024)
Median Wage
$78,140
per year
Mean Wage
$110,400
per year
Employment
472K
workers
Wage Range
$47,080 - $215,210
10th - 90th pct
Wage Distribution
Explore other career paths
Compare displacement risk across occupations and find careers with stronger long-term prospects.
Recommendations
Skills to Develop
These skills are at risk from AI automation. Securities and Commodities Traders professionals should diversify beyond them.
- Reading Comprehension
High reliance on Reading Comprehension is a risk area. Consider developing complementary AI-resistant skills to maintain value.
- Mathematics
High reliance on Mathematics is a risk area. Consider developing complementary AI-resistant skills to maintain value.
- Mathematics
High reliance on Mathematics is a risk area. Consider developing complementary AI-resistant skills to maintain value.
- Information Ordering
High reliance on Information Ordering is a risk area. Consider developing complementary AI-resistant skills to maintain value.
- Programming
Programming is AI-vulnerable but has moderate importance in this role. AI tools may handle this; focus on higher-value skills.
Skills to Leverage
These human-centric skills remain difficult for AI to replicate. Double down here.
- Adaptability/Flexibility
Adaptability/Flexibility is AI-resistant — strengthening this skill provides durable career protection.
- Negotiation
Negotiation is AI-resistant — strengthening this skill provides durable career protection.
- Social Perceptiveness
Social Perceptiveness is AI-resistant — strengthening this skill provides durable career protection.
- Persuasion
Persuasion is AI-resistant — strengthening this skill provides durable career protection.
- Complex Problem Solving
Complex Problem Solving is AI-resistant — strengthening this skill provides durable career protection.
Tools to Adopt
AI can amplify these skills. Learn the tools that augment rather than replace your work.
- Critical Thinking
Critical Thinking will be enhanced by AI. Develop expertise in using AI tools for this skill to increase productivity.
- Judgment and Decision Making
Judgment and Decision Making will be enhanced by AI. Develop expertise in using AI tools for this skill to increase productivity.
- Monitoring
Monitoring will be enhanced by AI. Develop expertise in using AI tools for this skill to increase productivity.
- Writing
Writing will be enhanced by AI. Develop expertise in using AI tools for this skill to increase productivity.
- Active Learning
Active Learning will be enhanced by AI. Develop expertise in using AI tools for this skill to increase productivity.
Score History
Risk score over 2 scoring runs
overall change